Fierras's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[TF2 Gun Sounds!]

if it has a .swf extention then it's a flash

I really don't get what people mean by it's not a flash...
So many things are submited to newgrounds that aren't drawn in vectors. I'm glad there is some variety in styles and techniques on NG.

Now with my review. I found the way it was edited a bit too repetitive. After a while i kinda drifted off and stoped paying attention to the animation because everything was happening so fast. I remember seeying this being done with CS sounds, this one has a ok beat to it as well.

[Noodles on my Back]

very catchy song

At the last shot the frames of the feet should of been put backwards because now they are walking towards the camera instead of toward the horizon.

[Compilation Jun'07-Apr'08]

I really liked it

You have a very smooth and liquid like style that I enjoy watching. You also mixed different types of media which always gives interesting results.

Keep it up

TheBoogley responds:

Julio! I just watched your show reel and I love your work, thanks for the kind words.

[Crows' Life Episode 3]

Entertaining

I enjoied watching this animation and you are very skilled. But it's too bad you don't spend the same amount of detail into your sound. The quality was good (except for Pauls recording) but the editing really needed a little bit more attention.

I also thought that some parts in the animation could use longer pauses.

I'm pointing out some things here but I really did enjoy it. Looking forward to the next episode.

Toonimated responds:

yea, some pauses may be needed, also, the original voices were spanish so the timing may be a bit different for the english ones.

[It's Over Nine-Thousand!]

didn't like it.

I didn't like the flash and frankly i'm surprised it has such a high score.

You basically combined images that other people took with an audiotrack that someone else made with an idea that has been done over 9000 times...

Sh0T-D0wN responds:

Actually some of those are by me.

Yes.

Lol.

[Birdthingy]

Quality too low to watch it the right way

I see that you compressed it to 1.3mb. You could of gone to at least 5mb and make the screensize a bit bigger or increase the frame rate.

I'm probably just repeating what most people have already said.

I've also seen this animation somewhere before but I can't remember where.

[The Promises]

Improve your drawing skills (technical stuff)

The effects were nice, but the guys face changed too much from each angle. When the girl moves her arm the upperarm stayed still...
The music is what probably made this tolerable.

Deadmen responds:

well, I admit, proportions of human body and backgrounds are my weak side. I'm still learning, and if you'll look through my flash as by "history of learning" you'll see how first scenes are crappiest, while in last ones I was improving, crafting my style.
Thanks for reasonable review!

[Tcasp Part3 The Thing]

Anything else would of been funny

You could of done anything with the story. Instead you chose to copy the show replacing some pedofile with a mainstream super hero who acts like he doesn't have any powers...

[School 13 - I.A.C.W.]

Fresh style

I would definitely would like to see more of your work. Very high quality. Keep it up.

Nightwayfarer responds:

thx. you'l definitely see more, because I am planing to be an animator in the future. 2 years more in gymnasium school, and then hello Art College :D (i hope i'l get there)

[Short Flash about Bill M.]

nice fountain reference

he's obviously Bill Murray